Another Conference at the Villa on Lake Wannsee
Eighty years ago, on 1 December 1944, an official meeting concerning future ‘sociological questions and tasks’ was held in the ‘Comradeship and Leadership House of the Security Police’, the former ‘Guesthouse of the Security Police and SD’. The gathering was chaired by Otto Ohlendorf, State Secretary in the Reich Ministry of Economics and SS Group Leader.
Research by Silke Struck
In the context of the Federal Ministry of Economics’ examination of its role in Nazi Germany, ministry employees attended a two-day training session at the Wannsee Memorial in 2017. While preparing for this seminar, I discovered files from a second important meeting that had also taken place in the Villa at Am Großen Wannsee 56-58, in the same building where the ‘Wannsee Conference’ was held. To this day, little is known about the men who attended this meeting on 1 December 1944 or what was discussed. The event was attended by 15 men from all areas of the Reich, including professors of various disciplines from the fields of anthropology, ethnology, law, sociology, political science, economics and political economy. Many of the attendees were active members of the NSDAP, the SA and/or the SS and, prior to the meeting at Wannsee, had worked intensively on issues relating to territory and settlement policy and so-called ‘Volkstumsfragen’ (ethnic issues) at their respective universities and institutes.
The participants included Prof Dr Alfred Jacobs1 and Dr Karl-Heinz Pfeffer2 from Berlin, Prof Dr Max-Hildebert Boehm and Dr Felix Boesler3 from Jena, Prof. Dr Martin Lohmann4 from Freiburg, Prof Dr Horst Jecht5 from Heidelberg, Prof Dr Erich Schäfer6 from Nuremberg, Dr Peter von Werder from Potsdam, Prof Dr Hans-Joachim Beyer7, Dr Karl-Valentin Müller8 and Dr Rudolf Hippius9 from Prague, Prof Dr Andreas Predöhl10 from Ratzeburg, Dr jur. Franz Ronneberger from Vienna, Oberregierungsrat Dr. Gerhard Isenberg from Wittenberg11 and Prof Dr Erich Egner12 from Ziegenrück.
Otto Ohlendorf, who hosted the meeting, was joined by employees from other ministries and a stenographer. Reinhard Heydrich's former close associate, Prof. Dr Reinhard Höhn13, was also present and made a few comments during the meeting.
The written speeches and shorthand notes of the discussion, preserved in the Federal Archives (Bundesarchiv, BArch), suggest that Ohlendorf's aim was to foster a scientific-political exchange between various special branches of science and ministry-level employees, who, in this case, were from the Reich Ministry of Economics. Ohlendorf was also interested in communicating the political interests of his ministry and developing plans for a future Germany, following its victorious defeat and the end of the war. By this time, however, it must have been clear to all the attendees that this goal was no longer attainable.
Sequence of Events
The participants met for the first time on the eve of the conference. They had been invited by Ohlendorf to an ‘informal gathering’ in the exclusive Hotel Excelsior at Anhalter Station. Most of the guests were staying at this conveniently-located hotel and travelled from there to Wannsee the following day. The meeting commenced at 9:30 in the morning. After three one-hour presentations by Professors Boehm, Ronneberger and von Werder, there was a lunch break and a brief discussion, after which Ohlendorf dominated the event with a nearly four-hour presentation. Later in the evening, as he bid farewell to the attendees, he announced that there would be further meetings in the future.
What do we know about the keynote speakers of the meeting on 1 December 1944 and what they discussed that day?
The Speakers
The day's program began with a lecture by Prof. Max Hildebert Boehm (1891-1968), who spoke about the current situation and tasks of sociology. He combined his remarks with a fundamental critique of the sociological science of the Weimar Republic and called for the establishment of a new ethnographic and social doctrine.
Born in Birkenruh in Livonia (Baltic), the art historian, philosopher and sociologist took an early interest in nationalist-ethnic topics. By World War I, Boehm had become concerned with ‘border and foreign Germanism’. From 1933 to 1945, he held a professorship for ‘Volkstheorie’ and ‘Volkstumsoziologie’ at the University of Jena. He supported the idea of a ‘Volksgemeinschaft’ (national-ethnic community) and the campaign to exclude from this community all people who, on the basis of descent criteria, were not of ‘German blood’. In 1933, Boehm began working as a consultant for the ‘Akademie für Deutsches Recht’ (Academy of German Law). In 1934, he became a supporting member of the SS. He was not accepted into the NSDAP, however, because of his criticism of Alfred Rosenberg's racial theories. In 1935, he published his work ‘Volkstheorie und Volkstumspolitik der Gegenwart’ and in 1936, the ‘ABC der Volkstumskunde’. In 1940, he published ‘Der befreite Osten’ with Christian von Loesch. Dismissed from the civil service after 1945, he founded the ‘Ostakademie’ in Lüneburg in the early 1950s, which later received state funding and focussed on refugee and expulsion policies.
The shorthand notes from 1 December 1944 quote him as follows:
‘We are living in a time when the whole world is clearly faced with the shaping of tasks, whose core lies in bringing together large masses of people, the solving and ordering of masses - [...].’14
Before this he had presented an abstract on the ‘State of Sociology’:
Prof Franz Ronneberger (1913-1999) was the next speaker on the list.
His talk has not been preserved, but it can be deduced from the shorthand notes of other participants that he spoke about ethnic issues (Volkstumsfragen) outside the Reich territory.
Born in Auma, Thuringia, the lawyer, social scientist and publicist joined the National Socialist Student Association and the SA in 1933. He joined the NSDAP in 1937 and the SS in 1942. Interested in the politics of ethnicity, Ronneberger began examining research on Southeast Europe at an early age and had close contacts with National Socialists in Hungary, Romania and Slovakia. In 1938, he wrote his doctoral thesis on ‘Southeast Europe in Bismarck's Political Order’ and presented Bismarck’s foreign policy as a model for the Nazi's expansionist foreign policy. From 1938 to 1945, he published numerous articles in the ‘Völkischer Beobachter’. The Vienna Reich Governor Arthur Seyß-Inquart recruited Franz Ronneberger to the staff of the Press Information Centre in 1939; in 1940, he was appointed by the Foreign Office to the newly established Southeast Office.
Like Otto Ohlendorf, his host in 1944, Ronneberger compiled situation reports and informed ministries and the Reich Security Main Office (RSHA) of his findings on events in Southeast Europe. He was aware of the persecution of Jews in this region and noted with admiration that it was a ‘radical solution to the Jewish question’. In spite of this, in the denazification process after 1945, he succeeded in presenting himself as an apolitical scientist. After being issued a fine in 1948 for his membership in the SS, he was able to pursue a successful career: he held a leadership position at the Westdeutsche Allgemeine Zeitung newspaper for many years. Later he worked for universities in Essen, Münster, Bielefeld, Erlangen, Nuremberg and Eichstädt and, as an influential instructor in the field of journalism, was granted the title of honorary senator in 1993. The Catholic University of Eichstädt-Ingolstadt did not revise this decision until 2023. After 1945, Ronneberger established the field of communication sciences and developed public relations theories.
The next lecture was given by Dr Peter August Hermann von Werder (1908-?). Von Werder spoke explicitly about his ideas on people and race and, like Otto Ohlendorf, commented on marriage and partner choice.
Between 1935 and 1941, the Berlin ethnologist and philosopher, who was born in Danzig, focussed intensively on West Africa and visited Sudan several times for research purposes. His sponsors and supporters included Dietrich Westermann from the Museum of Ethnology in Berlin, Prof. Fritz Krause from the Museum of Ethnology in Leipzig, Prof. Georg Thilenius from the Museum of Ethnology in Hamburg and Prof. Carl Meinhof from the Seminar on African Languages at the University of Hamburg. After publishing a few more classical ethnological studies on the sociology and languages of West Africa, Peter von Werder turned his attention to political issues. In 1938, he published the work ‘Gemeinschaft und Herrschaft als Staats- und Kulturtypen’ (Community and Rule as Forms of State and Culture). This was followed in 1941 by the books ‘Trugbild und Wirklichkeit im Film’ (Illusion and Reality in Film; reprinted in 1943) and ‘Die afrikanische Arbeiterfrage’ (The African Labour Question). This last title was commissioned by Dr Oskar Karstedt, assistant secretary in the Reich Ministry of Labour and head of the ‘Colonial Social Issues’ department. In late 1941/early 1942, Peter von Werder was appointed to the Department of Colonial Studies in the Rosenberg office.
At the conference, he stressed that the idea of ‘Volk’ was more important than ‘race’:
‘Race does not provide as great a form of differentiation regarding community as does Volk. Because by now the Volk has fused various races together under the leadership of a certain leading race.’15
Towards the end, Otto Ohlendorf (1907-1951) took the floor.
Otto Ohlendorf, the youngest of four children, was born to a farmer in Hoheneggelsen near Hanover. He attended grammar school in Hildesheim from 1917 to 1928. He joined the NSDAP on 28 May 1925 while still a pupil, and the SA and SS shortly thereafter. Active in the Göttingen area from 1929, his experienced his first success as a politician in Northeim, when he became district leader of the NSDAP before 1933. Between 1928 and 1931, he studied law in Leipzig and Göttingen. To gain an impression of the new political conditions under Benito Mussolini, the first fascist government in Europe, he attended the University of Pavia in Italy on a one-year scholarship. He wanted to study ‘fascism in situ’.16 Because of Ohlendorf’s involvement in so many different activities, his legal clerkship did not go well. He quit his legal training shortly before graduation in October 1933 to join the Institute for World Economics in Kiel and serve as an assistant to Professor Jens Jessen. In the mid-1930s, he moved to the Institute for Applied Economic Sciences in Berlin where he was appointed department head. In 1936, he joined the Security Service (SD) of the SS Main Office as Head of Department II/23 (Economics). His department received reports on the state of the economy that he revised and forwarded. In 1937, Ohlendorf became head of the domestic intelligence service of the SD and collected reports on the mood of the population in all ‘areas of life’ in the Reich. From autumn 1939, he was head of Office III in the newly formed Reich Security Main Office (Reichssicherheitshauptamt, RSHA) and submitted his ‘Reports from the Reich’ regularly until summer 1944. When the war against the Soviet Union began in summer 1941, Ohlendorf also took over the leadership of Einsatzgruppe D of the Security Police and SD. In so doing, he became a mass murderer: by June 1942, nearly 90,000 mostly Jewish-Ukrainian men, women and children were murdered by members of this Einsatzgruppe.
Ohlendorf continued to be active in the field of economic policy and in implementing the National Socialist ‘Volkstumspolitik’ – his main topic at the 1944 conference – which led to his promotion to Deputy State Secretary in the Reich Ministry of Economics in 1943. In 1944, he was appointed SS Group Leader and Lieutenant General of the Police. He was present in spring 1944, when the gold that had been stolen from murdered Jews was handed over to the Reichsbank in Berlin.
In October 1944, Otto Ohlendorf moved his official residence to the Villa on Lake Wannsee, which explains the choice of venue for the meeting. Two quotes from the meeting on 1 December 1944 show how strongly he was influenced by political and ideological thinking that day:
‘Here, too, we must take seriously the world view that we view the entire person [...] within the framework of the people (Volk) [...]. None of us who believes we have understood National Socialism and want to shape the content of National Socialism is denying the past; in fact, the past is a true legacy for us.’17
‘We will always regard [probably: consider] the foreign worker as a foreign national and treat him in such a way that he poses no danger to the German people.’
Arrested in 1945, Ohlendorf stood trial in 1946 and gave a detailed and open account of his crimes in Ukraine to the International Military Tribunal in Nuremberg. Otto Ohlendorf was sentenced to death on 10 April 1948 and executed in Landsberg on 7 June 1951.
The date of Peter von Werder's death is unknown. Reinhard Höhn died in 2000 and thus presumably lived longer than any of the other participants of the 1944 conference organised by Otto Ohlendorf. Höhn was never prosecuted for his involvement in Nazi racial policy. Until the 1980s, he and the other academics who attended the conference continued to shape teaching at German private and state institutes and universities as lecturers and professors.
6.3.1897 Schwerin-15.4.1972, 1922-1945 Statistisches Reichsamt (Reich Statistical Office), from 1939 Director of the Abteilung Sozialstatistik im Reichswirtschaftsministerium (Department of Social Statistics in the Reich Ministry of Economics), NSDAP member
↩28.12.1906 Frankfurt am Main-13.9.1971 Dortmund, Sociologist, NSDAP and SA member, Raumforschung (spatial research), Reichsnährstand
↩21.3.1901 Leipzig-5.9.1976, studied law, political science and finance, economist, advisor to Heinrich Himmler on financial policy issues relating to the ‘Generalplan Ost’ (‘Master Plan for the East’), NSDAP member
↩7.1.1901 Görlitz-Oktober 1965 Nancy (France), economist, financial scientist, NSDAP and SA member
↩14.6.1908 Geesthacht-25.8.1971 Hamburg, historian, Volkstumsforscher (folklore researcher), employee of the RSHA ‘Gegnerforschung’ (‘Opponent Research’), deployment in EG C, NSDAP, SA, SS member
↩26.3.1896 Bodenbach-3.8.1963 Nuremberg, sociologist, social anthropologist, racial biology studies in the Warthegau, University of Prague from 1941, worked for the Reinhard-Heydrich-Stiftung (Reinhard Heydrich Foundation), NSDAP member
↩9.6.1905 Schadriza-23.10.1945 Prague, psychologist, development of ‘Völkerpsychologie’, German-Baltic party Estonia, National Socialist renewal movement Estonia, 1939 stellvertretender Umsiedlungsleiter (deputy head of resettlement) Dorpat/Estonia
↩26.10.1893 Hamburg-18.7.1974 Münster, economist, from 1934 Director of Kieler Institut für Weltwirtschaft (Kiel Institute for World Economics), 1941-1945 Rector of Kiel University, NSDAP member
↩11.6.1902 Ulm-25.7.1982 Bonn, economist, Raum- und Siedlungsplanung (spatial and settlement planning)
↩19.6.1901 Ferdinandshof-24.8.1990 Göttingen, studied political science, economist, NSDAP member
↩29.7.1904 Gräfenthal-14.5.2000 Pöcking, lawyer, administrative scientist, from 1934 Hauptabteilungsleiter, SD-Hauptamt (Head of Department in the SD Main Office), NSDAP and SS member (1944 SS-Oberführer), member of the Akademie für Deutsches Recht (Academy for German Law), Ausschuss für Polizeirecht (Committee for Police Law), deputy to Dr Werner Best. 1935 to 1945 director of the Institut für Staatsforschung Berlin (Institute for State Research Berlin), 1941-1944 co-editor of the journal ‘Reich, Volksordnung, Lebensraum’ together with Dr Werner Best, Dr Gerhard Klopfer, Dr Wilhelm Stuckart and Rudolf Lehmann. Founder of an influential business academy in 1956, sentenced to pay a fine in 1958 due to his Nazi past.
↩Otto Ohlendorf's widow, Käthe Ohlendorf, cites Ohlendorf's motivation for going to Italy in a letter from 30 March 1979 to the British revisionist historian David Irving. IFZ, ZS-2356-1
↩