‘The Reich Ministry of Finance was a purely professional ministry.’

This is how Fritz Reinhardt, who served as State Secretary in the Reich Ministry of Finance throughout the twelve years of the Nazi era, described the agency in court on 14 October 1948. With this statement, he contributed to a post-war narrative that sought to exonerate all of the ministry’s employees at once. 

An essay by Silke Struck

Fritz Reinhardt was one of many former employees of the Reich Ministry of Finance who sought to cast the actions taken by the ministry and its employees in Nazi Germany in a favourable light after the war and construct a narrative that was neutral at the very least. This strategy, employed by the ministerial officials, strove to relativise the decisions they had made in office while simultaneously stressing their lawful nature. The conduct of the officials and employees of the Reich Ministry of Finance between 1933 and 1945 was far from ‘purely professional’. In reality, it was heavily influenced by policies that derived from the National Socialist ideology. This is particularly evident regarding the actions taken by senior staff members, including Reinhardt, at the end of the war and in the immediate post-war period.

State Secretary Fritz Reinhardt1 was one of two men who decisively influenced the financial administration during the Nazi era. The other was Reich Minister of Finance Johann Ludwig ‘Lutz’ Graf Schwerin von Krosigk.2

Both men held their positions from 1933 to 1945. Lutz Graf Schwerin von Krosigk had been appointed in 1932, thus taking up his post during the Weimar Republic. Fritz Reinhardt joined the ministry in the spring of the following year. He was assigned to the position following the dismissal of his predecessor, State Secretary Arthur Zarden,3 who had been appointed by Minister Schwerin von Krosigk. After the Nazis came to power, Zarden, who was of Jewish descent, was forced to leave the ministry in accordance with the Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service. He was replaced by Fritz Reinhardt, an ‘old fighter’ who had joined the NSDAP in 1923 and played a vital role in shaping tax and financial policy in Nazi Germany from 1933 and 1945. From the outset, population groups that were rejected on racial or political grounds were targeted by fiscally disadvantageous, discriminatory policies4 and their wealth was often plundered by the state. The Reich used the profits accrued from these measures to fund its policies. 

At the end of the war, Fritz Reinhardt tried to depoliticise and downplay his activities and those of the agency as a whole.

Porträt eines Mannes in einem dunklen Anzug mit Krawatte. Er hat kurze, glatte Haare und trägt eine Anstecknadel auf der linken Brustseite. Der Blick ist nach rechts gerichtet, und das Bild vermittelt einen ernsten Ausdruck.
© ÖNB
Fritz Reinhardt, undated [1930s]

Reinhardt's Career

After finishing school, Fritz Reinhardt, who was born and raised in Ilmenau, Thuringia, completed a business apprenticeship. In early 1919, he took his first major career step and became director of both the business school and the Academy for Economics and Taxation in Ilmenau. In 1922, he founded the tax consultancy firm ‘Deutsches Steuersyndikat’ in his hometown and was admitted as a tax agent to the Thuringia State Tax Office shortly thereafter. He also published ‘Rundschau für Wirtschaft und Steuer’, a trade magazine that was renamed ‘Wirtschaftlicher Beobachter’ in 1929. Reinhardt joined the NSDAP in 1923, which led to his dismissal as director of the business school in Ilmenau, and his subsequent departure from Thuringia. In 1924, he founded the Deutsche Fernhandelsschule, a German correspondence trade school in Herrsching am Ammersee, Bavaria. 

Parallel to his professional activities, Reinhardt built up his position within the party. In 1927, he became the district leader of the NSDAP in Upper Bavaria South, and from 1928 to 1930 he served as Gauleiter of Upper Bavaria. In 1929, he used his correspondence trade school to expand the NSDAP’s ‘Reichsrednerschule’, a speaker training school in Herrsching. He served as ‘Reich Propaganda Leader II’ in the NSDAP’s Reich leadership from 1930 to 1933 and was a Reichstag deputy throughout Hitler’s rule. On 1 April 1933, Fritz Reinhardt was appointed State Secretary in the Reich Ministry of Finance and remained in this position until the end of the war. In 1934, he made a name for himself in the Reich with the Tax Adaptation Act, which gave priority to ideological considerations when assessing the facts and circumstances of tax matters, and with the ‘Reinhardt Programme’, which aimed to eliminate unemployment. With the Tax Adaptation Act in particular, Reinhardt was largely responsible for the fiscal discrimination against political and racial opponents and, from 1942 onwards, for settling the accounts of assets and valuables stolen by the SS in connection with the mass murder of European Jews. In May 1945, he was arrested by American troops and, with minor interruptions, remained interned until 1949.5 The Munich Denazification Court classified Reinhardt as a major offender, sentencing him to internment and a fine, and banning him from practising his profession. He appealed these decisions and succeeded in having the penalties reduced in professional law proceedings. In the mid-1950s, he re-established himself as a tax expert in the private sector.

Covering their tracks in the final phase of the war

In February 1945, a circular from the Reich Ministry of Economics was distributed to the offices of the Reich, ordering that files relating to anti-Jewish activities be removed or, if this was not possible, immediately destroyed to prevent them from falling into the hands of the enemy.6 During his denazification proceedings in 1948, Reinhardt was confronted with this attempt by the ministry to manipulate files, and responded:

“The indictment accuses me of ordering the financial administration to ‘destroy secret files at the end of the war that could incriminate the Nazi Reich.’ First of all, I must point out that I was not aware of any files that might have ‘incriminated’ the Nazi regime. However, in my opinion, it goes without saying that during wartime, it is a national imperative that files which could help the enemy carry out its hostile aims should not be allowed to fall into their hands.”

Fritz Reinhardt’s reply to the indictment filed by the Chief Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation in Munich of 19.10.1948, Hauptstaatsarchiv München, SpkA K 1401, Spruchkammerakten Hauptkammer München, bound, section I

In his statement, Reinhardt first denies the allegations made against him before asserting that there is a ‘national imperative’ not to allow such files to fall into the hands of the enemy. His remark that no files ever existed that could have ‘incriminated the Nazi Reich’ is quite cynical, given the fiscal measures that he personally oversaw and advanced against ‘enemies of the Reich’.

Reinhardt did not shy away from manipulating files, particularly ones that concerned him directly: in 1949, Heinrich Schmittmann,7[1] former president of the Second Senate of the Reich Finance Court, exposed Reinhardt’s attempt to obtain his own tax file in April 1945 in an effort to create a ‘clean slate’ for himself in the post-war period. According to the senior attorney at the Reich and Federal Finance Court, when the Americans marched into Bavaria, Reinhardt ‘personally removed his tax file from the Starnberg tax office.’ Deeming this an attempt to unlawfully dispose of files, Schmittmann recorded it in the minutes. 

Ein beigelegter Brief mit dem Titel „Aktenvermerk“ zur Verfahren von Fritz Reinhardt. Der Brief enthält Informationen über eine Behörde und einen Bericht über persönliche Verhältnisse. Das Datum ist der 10. März 1949, und die Unterschrift stammt von einer Person mit dem Nachnamen „Meyer“.
© HStA München, SpkA-K 1401, Bl. 203
File memo from Reinhardt’s proceedings regarding a telephone call he had with Heinrich Schmittmann

Reinhardt did, in fact, succeed in obtaining his original personal tax file from the tax office and kept it in his possession. In 1949, it was presented to the Munich Denazification Court as evidence of Reinhardt’s financial situation in connection with the fine imposed on him.

Schmittmann, who had been associated with members of the Sperr Circle,8 an opposition group during the Nazi era, was classified as a ‘reusable’ civil servant after the war. He may have testified against Reinhardt to distract attention from his own ambivalent role under the Nazis. In 1935, Schmittmann had attended a lengthy speech held by State Secretary Reinhardt on the occasion of Ludwig Mirre’s inauguration as the new President of the Reich Finance Court. At the time, Schmittmann had publicly expressed his approval of his new boss. He wrote that his character guaranteed that ‘the management of the RFH would be entrusted to knowledgeable and proven hands and represent the National Socialist spirit.’9 In his speech in 1935, Reinhardt sent a clear message to the judges of the Reich Finance Court:

“Making laws is much easier today than in a parliamentary state. […] The Reich Finance Court assists the Reich Minister of Finance in interpreting and developing tax law in accordance with the principles of the National Socialist worldview within the meaning of § 1 StAnpG. It is the branch of the Reich Ministry of Finance that deals with questions of interpreting laws and developing National Socialist principles in German tax law. One of the most fundamental prerequisites for the work of every judge at the Reich Finance Court must therefore be that he familiarise himself with the principles of the National Socialist worldview and is himself imbued with the spirit of National Socialism.”

Fritz Reinhardt’s speech before the Reichs Finance Court, April 13, 1945, Steuerwarte No. 8, 1935, p. 179

Jurisprudence of the Reich Finance Court between 1933 and 1945, including that of the Second Senate under Schmittmann, was heavily influenced by these guidelines across all seven senate chambers of the highest German finance court, particularly regarding Jewish appellants.

The contradictory nature of Schmittmann’s actions is also demonstrated by statements he made following his appointment as President of the Federal Finance Court in 1950:

“The Reich Finance Court resisted attempts to have it reduced to the status of the minister’s assistant. Although one might have expected it to put up stronger resistance in this struggle, it has, nevertheless, […] repeatedly sought to avoid pressure and influence from the administration and to continue on the path towards maintaining adequate legal protection. […] The Federal Finance Court now faces new tasks with which it can rightly follow in the older tradition of the Reich Finance Court.”

Heinrich Schmittmann, Die öffentliche Verwaltung, December 1950, p. 700f.
Schwarz-weiß-Porträt eines Mannes, der in einem Anzug mit Krawatte zu sehen ist. Er hat kurze Haare und blickt direkt in die Kamera. Der Hintergrund ist neutral und trägt zur formellen Atmosphäre des Bildes bei.
© BArch, R9361 III
Dr Gerhard Klopfer (photographer unknown)

Dr Gerhard Klopfer, the character witness

Gerhard Klopfer, former State Secretary in the Party Chancellery and participant in the Wannsee Conference,10 was a key witness for the defence in the trial against Fritz Reinhardt. He too joined the ranks of the belittlers who pushed the narrative of an apolitical financial administration. 

Ein Dokument mit Überschrift „Amtliche Erklärung“ in deutscher Sprache. Es handelt sich um eine persönliche Erklärung bezüglich Dr. Gernard Klopfer, geboren 1905. Das Datum unten ist der 30. Dezember 1947, und das Dokument ist von einer Justizbehörde unterzeichnet.
© HStA München, SpkA-K 1401
Dr. Gerhard Klopfer’s affidavit from 30 December 1947

In the affidavit dated 30 December 1947 and reproduced here, Klopfer states that he was not aware of any involvement by Reinhardt in party politics.

Two years later, Dr Gerhard Klopfer was still willing to support Fritz Reinhardt. On 3 January 1949, he again confirmed the ‘neutral’ and professional conduct of the former State Secretary in the Reich Ministry of Finance and repeated his claim that Reinhardt had not held any office in the NSDAP:

“In his decisions and resolutions as State Secretary in the Reich Ministry of Finance, he was accountable only to his minister, Count Schwerin von Krosigk. Hence, he was not a political state secretary in the usual sense of a parliamentary system. [...] Reinhardt did not concern himself with matters outside the remit of the Reich Ministry of Finance or with high-level politics. To my knowledge, he also had no personal contact with leading figures in the party.”

Eidesstattliche Erklärung Dr. Gerhard Klopfer, 3. Januar 1949, Staatsarchiv München, SpkA K 1401, Spruchkammerakten Hauptkammer München, geheftet, Teil I, Blatt 33f.
Affidavit of Dr Gerhard Klopfer, 3 January 1949
© HStA München, SpkA K 1401
Affidavit of Dr Gerhard Klopfer, 3 January 1949
Affidavit of Dr Gerhard Klopfer, 3 January 1949
© HStA München, SpkA K 1401
Affidavit of Dr Gerhard Klopfer, 3 January 1949

Another prominent character witness, in addition to Dr Gerhard Klopfer, was the aforementioned former President of the Reich Finance Court, Ludwig Mirre. Mirre and Reinhardt worked together to arrange the Führer’s tax exemption in 1934. They argued that, based on the Führer’s constitutional status, he was not liable for tax and that it was a matter of state policy whether and to what extent the Führer should be treated as a normal taxpayer.11 One year after this ‘Caesar rule’ was established, Mirre became president of the Reich Finance Court.

Reinhardt’s influence on the training of tax officials in the post-war period

In 1949, Fritz Reinhardt mentioned that, after the war, he continued to have a significant influence on the training of tax officials, and noted in passing that both the teaching materials on tax issues that he created during the Nazi era, as well as the teachers he hired to teach the material, were still in place. Reinhardt was aware that this continuity in the financial administration was significant:

“Between 1935 and 1939, I introduced and developed a new training and further education system in the Reich Finance Administration. This system will probably continue to serve as the foundation for the training and education of tax officials in Germany for all eternity. Today’s state financial administrations maintain finance and customs schools, which are a continuation of the Reich finance and customs schools that I created between 1935 and 1939. Former teachers from my Reich finance and customs schools are now employed at these schools, and the teaching materials I created for my Reich finance and customs schools are still being used.”

Fritz Reinhardt comments on documents in his denazification trial file, 25 May 1949, Hauptstaatsarchiv München, SpkA K 1401, Spruchkammerakten Hauptkammer München, bound, section I, pp. 48-49

After the restrictions on his professional activities were lifted in 1953,12 the former State Secretary in the Reich Ministry of Finance developed new teaching materials and reestablished himself as a successful author of works on tax, economics, and popular science. These materials were used until the 1960s by the finance schools operated by the federal government. They continued to shape the self-image of entire generations of financial officials who saw themselves as part of a ‘purely’ politically neutral ‘professional administration’.

The post-war narrative shaped by senior financial administration officials served to exonerate everyone involved in the ministry and, for many decades, concealed the fact that, within the scope of their respective powers,13 civil servants at all levels radically pursued and implemented the National Socialist goals set by the ministry between 1933 and 1945. 

 

 

3 April 1895 in Ilmenau – 17 June 1969 in Regensburg, State Secretary in the Reich Finance Ministry, 1933-1945, NSDAP member since 1923, Party Speaker, responsible for the Reich finance schools, sentenced as a major offender to three years in prison. 

↩

22 August 1887 in Rathmannsdorf – 4 March in 1977 in Essen, Reich Finance Minister for the governments of Papen, von Schleicher, Hitler and Dönitz from 1932 to 1945. As part of the personal union under Dönitz, Lutz Graf Schwerin von Krosigk assumed the dual roles of foreign minister and finance minister. After being awarded the Golden Party Badge of Honour by Hitler, he joined the NSDAP in 1937. Arrested and interned on 23 May 1945, he was sentenced to 10 years’ imprisonment at the Nuremberg Trials in 1949, but was released in 1951 under an amnesty. As a publicist and writer, he published several works, including his “Persönliche Erinnerungen” (personal memories) in 1974 and in 1975 “Staatsbankrott”, (state bankruptcy), a book on financial policy from 1920 to 1945. 

↩

17 April 1885 Hamburg – 18 January 1944 Berlin. Arthur Zarden was removed from office on the basis of § 6 (simplification of the administration, forced early retirement) of the Law for the ‘Restoration of the Professional Civil Service’. See here: RGBl. I 1933, p. 175, 7 April 1933. In 1943, Zarden belonged to the group associated with the Solf Circle. He was arrested in 1944 on charges of undermining military morale. He jumped out the window of the Berlin prison where he was being held and died from injuries incurred during the fall.  

↩

§ 1 of the Tax Adaption Act of 1934 prescribes the direction in which the administration should act. “Tax laws should be interpreted according to the National Socialist world view,” RGBl. I 1934, p. 925

↩

Reinhardt was held in the internment camp run by the American military in Dachau from 1 May 1945 to 1948. He was also temporarily interned in Nuremberg, Moosbach and München-Freimann until his release after his work camp sentence was reduced from four to three years. He was furloughed from internment several times to give testimony as a witness or defendant in various trials.

↩

See: Joseph Walk, Das Sonderrecht für die Juden im NS-Staat. Eine Sammlung der gesetzlichen Maßnahmen und Richtlinien - Inhalt und Bedeutung, Heidelberg, Karlsruhe 1981, Entry 16 February 1945

↩

Heinrich Schmittmann, 2 December 1878 in Düsseldorf - 2 June 1956 in Munich. Heinrich Schmittmann was president of the Düsseldorf tax office from 1925 to 1933. Due to his connections with the Centre Party and at the instigation of the NSDAP Düsseldorf, he was forced out of office in the summer of 1933 and transferred to the Reich Finance Court as president of the Second Senate. He held this position until 1945. After the war, he served as President of the Supreme Finance Court until 1950 and President of the Federal Finance Court until 1951. 

↩

On the resistance group against Hitler organised around Franz Sperr, Eduard Hamm and Otto Geßler, see: Manuel Limbach, Bürger gegen Hitler, Vorgeschichte, Aufbau und Wirken des Bayerischen „Sperr-Kreises“, Göttingen 2019. 

↩

Steuerwarte No. 8, 1935, p. 180

↩

18 February 1905 in Schreibersdorf – 29 January 1987 in Ulm. He participated in the Wannsee Conference in 1942 as State Secretary in the Reich Chancellery and Ministerial Director in the Party Chancellery of the NSDAP. In 1952, Klopfer worked as an assistant in tax matters. In 1956, he worked as a solicitor in Ulm. For more information on the biography of Dr Gerhard Klopfer, see Markus Heckmann, in: Die Teilnehmer, Berlin, 2017, p. 181-196.

↩

Der Spiegel 15/1970, Von Steuern befreit

↩

Restrictions were placed on Reinhardt’s professional activities on 17 June 1949. In 1953, the Bavarian Office of the Minister for Political Liberation mitigated the ruling and allowed Reinhardt to work as a freelance expert writer on accounting and tax matters. In 1952, the Hauptkammer München had already ruled that Reinhardt could resume work as an employee in a senior position.

↩

A commission of historians was established in 2009 to research the history of the ministry. On the commission’s findings, see Christiane Kuller, Bürokratie und Verbrechen. Antisemitische Finanzpolitik und Verwaltungspraxis im nationalsozialistischen Deutschland, Munich 2013; Jürgen Kilian, Krieg auf Kosten anderer. Das Reichsministerium der Finanzen und die wirtschaftliche Mobilisierung Europas für Hitlers Krieg, Munich 2017; Ralf Banken, Hitlers Steuerstaat, Die Steuerpolitik im Dritten Reich, Munich 2018.

↩